Non-Qualified Retirement Plan: What It Is and How It Works?

In order to attract and keep the best employees for the company, employers now need to do more than provide a basic benefits package. Businesses are always trying to find new ways to reward their executives and high-income earners, including implementing a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan (NQRP). NQRPs do not need to follow the rigid contributions and payout restrictions set by the IRS like traditional retirement plans do, making them more accessible. But what exactly are they, and who stands to gain the most? This guide from NHI Money explains the essentials of non-qualified retirement plans, their benefits, and how they’re used in executive compensation strategies.

What Is a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan?

What Is a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan?

A non-qualified retirement plan (NQRP) is a type of unqualified savings plan one’s employer may offer without adhering to the stipulations of qualified programs, including 401(k)s and IRAs. These plans are tailored to provide additional financial cushioning. They are designed for strategically important employees, mostly executives or high-earning individuals. Unlike traditional programs, these plans have no limits on contributions or compliance requirements.

Standard retirement plans are under the control of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) while non-qualified ones exist outside this context and therefore are not subject to it. This allows more freedom and flexibility to commercially restrictive practices concerning the sponsorship of the plan and the allocation of the benefits. Below, we’ll explore why these plans are particularly beneficial for high earners and how they differ from their qualified counterparts.

Provide extra retirement benefits for executives and high-income earners

Highly paid employees often find that contribution limits imposed on retirement plans like 401(k)s makes them more difficult to save when compared to other options which renders these options useless. Having the option to use a non-qualified retirement plan gives executives an additional wedge of income to save whilst not being restrictive in the longevity or longevity of the accrual.

These plans are used by companies trying to keep and attract top tier talent. With NQRP’s, employers now have the flexibility to tailor retirement saving plans to include bonuses, stock options, or even deferred compensation agreements which allow high earners a more flexible approach to retirement savings.

How it differs from qualified retirement plans

Although both qualified and non-qualified plans can be used for retirement savings, there are some important differences:

• Regulatory compliance: Qualified plans must meet specific criteria set forth by the IRS and ERISA like reporting obligations, but NQRPs do not have to worry about compliance.
• Tax treatment: Depending on the structure of the plan, contributions to the non-qualified plans may be made pre or post tax, and withdrawals often have tax consequences.
• Participation: Participation in qualified plans must be extended to all eligible employees, but non-qualified plans are selective and can be offered to executives and key employees only.
• Employer control: Employers have greater control over the design and administration of a NQRP, including the terms and conditions for payment and vesting.

It’s important for an employer seeking to offer compensation packages to understand the employees’ needs for a financially secure future, and vice versa. In the next section, we’ll discuss the working of these plans along with their implementation and the most important steps of each.

How Do Non-Qualified Retirement Plans Work?

How Do Non-Qualified Retirement Plans Work?

NQRPs, or Non Qualified Retirement Plans, are unlike any other traditional retirement plans that come with a cap and rigid structure. As the name suggests, NQRPs are unqualified and non-compliant in nature enabling higher flexibility, providing selective benefits to a smaller target group of employees. These are generally offered as a compensatory advantage to select employees and high income achievers allowing them to save above and beyond what qualified plans permit. Here’s how they work, step by step.

Step 1. Employer offers a custom retirement savings option

The employer creates a non-qualified retirement plan that fits the specific requirements of the company and its compensation strategy. While 401(k) plans must be made available to all eligible employees, an NQRP can be crafted particularly for executives and other crucial personnel. Employers outline details such as contribution limits, payout conditions, and vesting schedules for the plan.

Step 2. Employees and/or employers contribute pre-tax or after-tax dollars

Both the employee and the employer, or one party on their own, may contribute to a non-qualified retirement plan. Depending on the non-qualified plan’s design, either pre-tax or post-tax dollars may be used to make contributions. Non-qualified plans, unlike 401(k) that require employees to defer a portion of their salary, offer a looser funding method.

Step 3. Contributions grow tax-deferred, but taxation depends on the plan structure

A primary benefit in NQRPs is that contributions accrue on a tax-deferred basis, akin to a Qualified Retirement Plan. However, rules for taxation differ depending on the plan type. In numerous instances, employees are not liable for taxes on contributions until they receive distributions. Employers, however, need to carefully design the plan to comply with tax laws while still providing favorable terms.

Step 4. Payouts occur based on a set agreement or upon retirement

The funds in a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan are dispersed according to specific arrangements made between the employer and employee. Payment may be made in retirement, upon reaching a milestone, or scenarios such as termination or disability. Unlike 401k’s, with attendant required minimum distribution (RMD) rules, NQRPs are more flexible in terms of timing withdrawals, which facilitates income planning for executive-level employees.

In this manner, nonqualified retirement plans ensure flexibility for businesses that want to retain great employees while providing high-earning employees the ability to factor their financial planning more precisely. We will look at what coverage options there are for nonqualified retirement plans in the next section.

Further reading:

• Life Insurance Retirement Plan
• 9 Best Chase Business Credit Cards
• 7 Best Personal Finance Apps

Types of Non-Qualified Retirement Plans

There are many kinds of non-qualified retirement plans and each is aimed at meeting the diverse financial planning requirements of high level executives and earners. These plans allow for employers to strategically reward key employees as well as make provisions for long-term savings apart from the conventional retirement accounts.

Deferred Compensation Plans

These plans enable an employee to reserve specific portions of their salary for a later date. Usually at retirement or other selected date for payment. Plans for deferred compensation are usually organized as salary deferral arrangements under which income tax on the deferred earnings is delayed until the funds are withdrawn. This arrangement is particularly appealing to high income earners as their taxable income during the years of greatest earning is significantly reduced. Deferred compensation plans are also flexible and can be designed in many different ways to help employees with post-retirement financial planning. Including paying the benefit in a lump-sum or over time.

Executive Bonus Plans

An executive bonus plan otherwise referred to as Section 162 plan pertains to providing extra benefits for a select few employees, usually managers, often under the form of a life insurance plan. The employer covers payment of the premiums while the employee is the policy holder. This plan has an immediate tax benefit for the employer, meanwhile, employees are able to access cash value accumulation within the policy for use during retirement or other needs. Executive bonus plans have wide appeal because of the low administrative burdens placed on them while providing employees with cash options unlike conventional retirement plans.

Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans (SERPs)

SERPs are part of the retirement plans of a company which an employer funds primarily to serve as a head start to other retirement benefits an executive gets. Unlike the unpaid portion of a pension plan, SERPs do not require contributions from employees. For retention of key talent, these plans are often offered as golden handcuffs, providing large payouts to encourage long term commitment to the company as well as major milestones such as retirement. SERPs can be designed with vesting conditions to promote achievement of company targets and help guarantee that executives remain with the firm while accumulating sufficient funds to enjoy retirement.

Split-Dollar Life Insurance

This is an arrangement type where an employer and employee jointly own a life insurance policy. The employer usually pays for the premium cost and has a policy interest stake in its cash value or death benefit. This helps to obtain tax benefits while enabling executives to accumulate substantial wealth over time and also provide a financial safety net for their family. 

Several custom options are available for non-qualified retirement plans to meet the objectives of employees and employers. Next, we’ll explain the main features from the participants’ perspective.

Benefits of a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan

Benefits of a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan

Non-qualified retirement plans offer noteworthy benefits to employers and employees alike. Flexibility of saving, potential for greater savings, and tax strategies mark these plans’ advantages. Below are the key benefits:

Higher Contribution Limits

Higher contribution limits are one of the primary advantages of a non-qualified retirement plan (NQRP). Unlike every other retirement account, NQRPs allow users to deposit funds in excess of common traditional plans’ or retirement accounts’ contribution limits. 401(k) plans, for example, include an annual contribution cap of $23,000 in 2024. These limits could prove to be restrictive for high earners who are looking to save more funds for retirement.

It is a lot easier to save with NQRPs since there is no cap posed by the IRS on contributions. Employers would be able to draft policies that are flexible enough to permit top-level executives and vital employees to defer whatever amount of income they choose, thus enabling their retirement savings to surpass standard caps. Traditional 401(k) plans or IRAs greatly restrain the ability of executives looking to expand their retirement funds. Therefore, non-qualified plans serve as an ideal solution – providing the necessary freedom.

Flexible Payout Options

Non-qualified arrangements have fewer payout restrictions than qualified ones, which have Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) policies that kick in at age 73. The flexibility offered in non-qualified plans is enhanced by the freedom given to the employers and employees to create their own payout schedules that fit with their long-term financial objectives, such as:

• Lump-sum payment: Participants can decide to get the full amount of their balance at the time of retirement or any other specified time.
• Installment payments: The balance can be spread over several years. For example, 5, 10, or 20 years, ensuring a regular income in the employee’s retirement years.
• Deferred payout: Withdrawals can be postponed to a later date through an election, which can be strategic when planning taxes.

Non-qualified arrangements are especially helpful to senior executives with several income streams and need to streamline their tax liabilities in retirement.

Employer-Controlled and Customizable

A notable characteristic of NQRPs is that they are not subject to ERISA rules. This gives employers more freedom in deciding who qualifies, contributes, and receives benefits. Unlike qualified retirement plans, which require equal treatment for all employees, non-qualified plans offer more flexibility. Employers can choose to offer these plans at their discretion. This allows businesses to use them strategically to attract and retain talented employees.

There is flexibility for employers to change:

• Eligibility criteria: geared towards executives, key personnel, or employees who have served or performed above a certain level.
• Vesting thresholds: payouts may be dependent on achieving certain performance goals or staying with the company to ensure the executive stays active with the company.
• Funding methods: the employer chooses whether to fund the plan at once (e.g., via a Rabbi Trust) or let it stay as an unfunded liability on the company’s balance sheet until payment is due.

NQRPs are especially effective retention tools for strategic businesses that aim to provide long-term financial incentives to leadership teams.

Potential Tax Deferral

A major financial advantage of NQRPs is tax-deferred growth. Allowing employees to defer taxes on contributions and investment earnings until the funds are withdrawn. These tactics, in particular, can be helpful for people with higher earnings who are hoping to lower their economic burden during the current tax period.

Here’s how it works:

• Employees’ taxable income is lowered for the year through the deferral of a portion of their bonus or salary.
• The portion eligible for deferral is untaxed while in the plan.
• The payout when received will be subject to ordinary income tax, however, the individual is likely to be in a lower bracket post retirement.

Taxation regulations depend greatly upon the NQRP’s structure. Some NQRPs provide the ability to make after-tax contributions so that withdrawals will not be taxed during retirement. Others may require full taxation upon distribution. Both employers and employees should grasp the taxation consequences of a non-qualified plan when attempting to create a desirable retirement plan.

As devised, these benefits serve to make non-qualified retirement plans very q-valuable for both business and the executive. They present a higher degree of potential savings, along with a favorable greater accessibility degree and a tax exemption. Making it very attractive for highly compensated individuals who wish to go beyond IRS limits when planning for retirement.

Who Should Consider a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan?

Who Should Consider a Non-Qualified Retirement Plan?

Not everyone can benefit from a non-qualified retirement plan. And it is a good fit for certain types of people and businesses that want more options for retirement benefits and compensation planning. The following are the primary users who will take maximum advantage of these plans:

Executives and High-Income Earners

Like other retirement plans, non-qualified ones allow setting aside extra money for retirement. This type of plan enables high-income earners to set aside a portion of their income while their savings continue to grow without being subjected to immediate taxation; effectively deferring the high tax burden.

Moreover, many executives are compensated with bonuses and stock options. A non-qualified retirement plan enables the deferral of these amounts. So the taxpayer isn’t subject to an excessive tax burden during a given high income year. This method can greatly assist building assets and provide needed income during retirement.

Business Owners

Business owners who want to personally reward themselves or key employees with retirement compensation can use NQRPs. These plans help design long-term compensation strategies. They are useful because profits stay within the business. At the same time, the company’s leadership is financially secure in the future.

In addition, business owners can use non-qualified plans to reduce their taxable income over time. With an NQRP, earnings can be shifted to years with lower tax rates. This makes tax efficiency much better. Thanks to their flexibility, non-qualified plans are very appealing. They help business owners improve their finances both personally and professionally.

Companies Looking to Retain Top Talent

To remain competitive, companies in today’s job market must use new and innovative methods. These approaches help attract and retain high-level executives. Non-qualified plans have proven to be effective in keeping talent. They offer financial rewards tied to longevity in the company.

Companies can create retention vesting schedules and payout structures. These promote rewarding employees and help ensure organizational success. For example, a deferred compensation plan may require an executive to stay with the company for a certain number of years before accessing the funds.

You might also like:

• How to Build Wealth: A Guide to Long-term Success
• How To Build Generational Wealth For Financial Freedom
• Financial Calculators

Alternatives to Non-Qualified Retirement Plans

Alternatives to Non-Qualified Retirement Plans

Non-qualified retirement plans are flexible and highly customizable, but will not fit everyone. There are other retirement plans which come with various features such as different tax advantages, contribution limits, and guaranteed payouts. Following are some alternatives that need to be examined.

401(k) Plans

A 401(k) plan serves as a company sponsored plan that enables employees to put away a portion of their earnings before tax. A benefit of this would include lowering taxable income while increasing retirement funds actively.

Key benefits of a 401(k) Plan:

• Gains are taxed: Unlike retirement plans, investment gains for personal accounts are taxed as capital gains.
• Lack of employer contributions: There is no employer matching contribution as seen in 401(k) plans.
• Market volatility: The market largely determines the value of the investment, and there can be fluctuations.
• Self-managed or with professional help: The individual makes the choice to manage their portfolio or hire an advisor.

Considerations for a 401(k) Plan:

• Withdrawals will incur taxation: Regular retirement withdrawals will be subject to taxation as income.
• Penalties for early withdrawals: Withdrawals made prior to age 59 ½ carry a 10% penalized tax along with other taxes.
• Mandatory minimum withdrawals: All account holders must begin to withdraw funds from their accounts when they reach 73 years of age.

A 401(k) serves as a powerful tool for retirement savings, especially with employer contributions. Adequate groundwork maximizes benefits while reducing tax burden associated during retirement.

Roth IRA

A Roth IRA is an individual account that allows for tax-free withdrawals in the retirement phase. This account is different from traditional retirement accounts because contributions are made after tax. That means tax is paid initially, but the earning amount over a period of time will not be taxed.

Key benefits of a Roth IRA:

• Tax-free growth: As long as withdrawal rules are followed, there is no taxation on investment growth.
• Tax-free withdrawals: Exemption from taxes is given for qualified withdrawal during retirement which greatly increases savings.
• No required minimum distributions (RMDs): Funds do not have to be withdrawn at a specific age.
• Flexible contributions: Employed individuals of any age can contribute if they have earned income.

Considerations for a Roth IRA:

• After-tax contributions: Contributions do not have tax-deductible benefits like in 401(k) plans.
• Income excludes certain values: Earnings above a certain limit can make individuals ineligible to directly contribute to a Roth IRA.
• Five-year superseding rule: Withdrawals on earnings are only tax-free after 5 years.

Roth IRA enable a retirement plan for individuals who are expected to be in a higher tax bracket. Flexibility in the long run at a lower tax bracket with a Roth IRA aid turns it into an effective retirement plan.

Defined Benefit Pension Plans

Retirees are issued a set level of income on the basis of their salary and service years with a supported defined benefit pension plan. These pensions are set in stone and do not increase or decrease with the performance of one’s personal investment unlike 401k’s.

Key benefits of a Defined Benefit Pension Plan:

• Fixed amount of income after retirement along with aid of wages is called guarantee lifetime income enabling financial security.
• Demand free: Employees are not allowed to put in any money themselves, aid turns the burden off for workers.
• Financial stability of post-retirement is considered predictable through set formula payouts enabling receiving of defined amounts.
• Possible adjustment after the set rate of income: Certain plans can offer improvement to outpace inflation.

Considerations for a Defined Benefit Pension Plan:

• Limited employee control: Employees do not directly manage funds or decide their input to the defined benefit pension plan.
• Vesting requirements: Eligibility for full benefits may necessitate spending a certain minimum duration with the employer.
• Company solvency risks: Pension payouts might be available if the employer is facing difficult financial situations.
• Declining availability: Due to sustaining financial pressure, there is a decreased number of defined benefit plans available.

Defined benefit pension plans have restrictions and reliance on employer solvent status but do promise a consistent retirement income. Terms of the plan need to be known to safeguard employees’ long term monetary plans.

Personal Investment Accounts

Outside of company-sponsored plans, one such account is a personal investment account which allows all the freedom for retirement savings. Unlike 401k and IRAs, these accounts do not impose restrictions on the amount of money that can be withdrawn/added or withdrawn early.

Key benefits of a Personal Investment Account:

• Withdrawals and deposits: Investors can withdraw funds or deposit them whenever they want, without any added fees.
• Contribute without limits: There is no set amount that you are restricted to invest in a year.
• Versatile options: Various elements stocks such as bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, and properties can be invested in real estate.
• No required minimum distributions (RMDs): Investors can determine when and how they want their funds distributed.

Considerations for a Personal Investment Account:

• Gains are taxed: Unlike retirement plans, investment gains for personal accounts are taxed as capital gains.
• Lack of employer contributions: There is no employer matching contribution as seen in 401(k) plans.
• Market volatility: The market largely determines the value of the investment, and there can be fluctuations.
• Self-managed or with professional help: The individual makes the choice to manage their portfolio or hire an advisor.

A Personal Investment Account is appealing thanks to its control and accessibility; however, meticulous tax planning is essential. This investment account is perfect for individuals looking to supplement retirement accounts outside set limitations.

Every alternative has its clear advantages and disadvantages. A combination of an individual’s financial goals, appetite for risk, and tax parameters determine the optimal choice. Knowing the differences between accounts aid employees and employers with informed decisions regarding retirement planning.

FAQs